Jump to Recipe

Let’s be honest—sometimes, you just want ice cream. But not the kind that leaves you in a sugar coma or blows your macros. That’s exactly why I created this low calorie high protein ice cream with Greek yogurt—it’s cold, creamy, slightly tangy, and totally scoopable… without the guilt.

It all started when I was deep into a summer meal prep binge. I had extra frozen bananas and an open container of plain Greek yogurt in the fridge. Instead of blending up a smoothie (again), I tossed everything into a food processor, added a bit of vanilla protein and a pinch of stevia, and what came out was this magical soft serve-style treat that felt like dessert—but totally fit my protein goals.

You don’t need an ice cream machine. You don’t need a long ingredient list. And you definitely don’t need to give up flavor to get that protein in.

How To Make High Protein Ice Cream With Greek Yogurt

This low calorie high protein ice cream with Greek yogurt couldn’t be easier. It starts with one very ripe banana—sliced and frozen until solid. This gives you that creamy base without needing cream or sugar.

Into the blender it goes, along with Greek yogurt, a scoop of vanilla whey, a splash of vanilla, and just enough sweetener to hit the spot. I like using liquid stevia, but any zero-calorie sweetener works.

Blend until smooth and creamy. If it’s too thick, add a tablespoon or two of almond milk to loosen it up. From here, you can eat it right away as soft serve (so good!), or freeze it for 2–3 hours in a shallow container until it firms up to scoopable perfection.

If you like desserts with Greek yogurt check out my recipe on How To Make Greek Yogurt Berry Bark – Easy High Protein

Tips, Variations & Storage Ideas

One of the things I love most about this low calorie high protein ice cream with Greek yogurt is how incredibly flexible it is. Once you’ve made it once, you’ll probably want to start tweaking it based on your favorite flavors or what you have on hand. Here are my best tips and ideas to keep your protein ice cream smooth, satisfying, and totally crave-worthy.

👩‍🍳 Tips for the Creamiest Results

Use a ripe banana. The riper the banana, the sweeter the base—and it also blends smoother.

Don’t skip the protein powder. The whey protein helps create a creamy, fluffy texture while adding major protein. If you leave it out, your ice cream will still be good—but less creamy and less filling.

Blend until completely smooth. Let your blender or food processor run long enough to break everything down into soft serve consistency. If your blender struggles, add a small splash of almond milk to help.

Eat it soft serve-style right after blending if you’re short on time—or freeze for a scoopable version later.

🍦 Flavor Variations to Try

This low calorie high protein ice cream with Greek yogurt is just a starting point! Try some of these easy swaps:

Chocolate version: Use chocolate whey protein and add 1 tsp cocoa powder.

Berry swirl: Add ½ cup frozen strawberries or blueberries to the blend.

Peanut butter twist: Add 1 tbsp powdered peanut butter or a spoonful of PB before blending.

Dairy-free: Swap Greek yogurt for a high-protein coconut or almond-based yogurt, and use plant-based protein powder.

❄️ Storage Tips

To store your low calorie high protein ice cream with Greek yogurt, transfer it to a shallow airtight container, like a silicone loaf pan or glass meal prep dish. Smooth the top with a spoon and press a layer of parchment or plastic wrap directly onto the surface. This helps prevent freezer burn and ice crystals.

It will firm up after 2–3 hours in the freezer. For best texture, let it sit at room temperature for 5–10 minutes before scooping. The ice cream is best enjoyed within 5–7 days, although mine rarely lasts that long!

Whether you’re craving a post-dinner treat or a mid-day protein boost, this low calorie high protein ice cream is the perfect way to satisfy your sweet tooth without sabotaging your macros.